Fact Check: Deepfake Tech Used to Create This Call Between Swati Maliwal & Dhruv Rathee
A recording of a telephonic conversation purportedly between Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leader Swati Maliwal and YouTuber Dhruv Rathee is going viral on social media.
What can he heard?: In the viral clip, Maliwal explains to Rathee how she was assaulted in front of Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and his wife Sunita Kejriwal.
She further requests Rathee not to make any video on this to defend them.
Further, Rathee also tells her that he gets paid by directly from the UK.
Background: Maliwal registered a complaint to Delhi Police and alleged that she was attacked by Kejriwal's aide, Bibhav Kumar on 13 May, inside the CM's residence.
Kumar has, however, denied the allegation. Following this, the Delhi police arrested Kumar on 18 May, and he is currently in the police custody.
Rathee's role: Rathee made a video on the incident and raised questions on the authenticity of this complaint.
Archives of more claims on social media can be seen here.
What's the truth?: The audio in this video has been created using a deepfake technology.
How did we find out the truth?: There was no mention of this conversation of Maliwal and Rathee's social media profiles.
No report about this was covered by the media either.
We also noticed that at the 0:09 timestamp, there is a jump-cut and then an overlay of two voices/sentences.
AI detection tool: After examining the audio using AI detection tools, the Misinformation Combat Alliance’s (MCA) Deepfakes Analysis Unit (DAU) concluded that the audio is synthetic.
The voice detection tool of Loccus.ai indicated that this audio has more probability of being fake.
DAU also ran the audio through TrueMedia’s deepfake detector which overall categorised the audio as “highly suspicious”.
In a further breakdown of the analysis, the tool gave a 100 percent confidence score to the subcategory of “audio analysis” and a 99 percent confidence score to “advanced foundational features” — both indicators that it is highly probable that an AI audio generator was used to synthesise this audio.
The low confidence score of nine percent to the “AI generated audio detection” category suggests that the tool has more confidence in the audio having been synthesised using AI, and that it is not fully AI-generated.
DAU also used the AI speech classifier of ElevenLabs, a company specialising in voice AI research and deployment. The results indicated that there was a very high probability that the audio file was generated using their software.
ElevenLabs also told the DAU that after analysing the audio they were able to identify the user who had used their software to generate this audio. They added that they have banned that account from using any of their tools in the future.
ElevenLabs also told the DAU that after analysing the audio they were able to identify the user who had used their software to generate this audio. They added that they have banned that account from using any of their tools in the future.
They also mentioned that it is possible that techniques such as Retrieval-based Voice Conversion (RVC) cloning or Text-to-Speech (TTS) cloning were used to generate these voices.
Conclusion: Several deepfake detection tools confirmed that the viral clip allegedly between Swati Maliwal and Dhruv Rathee has been generated using AI.
The fact check was first published by The Quint and republished by Deccan Chronicle as part of Shakti Collective.
